Congenital Adrenal Hyperplasia: A Critical Appraisal of the Evolution of Feminizing Genitoplasty and the Controversies Surrounding Gender Reassignment

Abstract

Although congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH) is the most common cause of genital ambiguity, its surgical treatment remains controversial and often times difficult, especially in cases of high urethro-vaginal confluence. Many aspects are still uncertain, such as the timing of feminizing genitoplasty and type of surgical technique. The objective of this study is to provide a thorough review of the surgical management of children with CAH, discussing the evolution of feminizing genitoplasty and its different techniques, and also to critically appraise the available literature on the timing of surgical intervention and gender reassignment. Prospective long-term studies evaluating the results of modern feminizing genitoplasty techniques are needed as current evidence is based on outdated operations that are no longer used. To date, there have been no studies comparing early and delayed feminizing genitoplasty with regard to psychological outcomes. All families should be counseled regarding the controversies and treatment options, including the watchful waiting approach.

congenital adrenal hyperplasia - ambiguous genitalia - feminizing genitoplasty - urogenital sinus - gender reassignment

References

• 1 Miller WL. Genetics, diagnosis, and management of 21-hydroxilase deficiency.  J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 1994;  78 241-246
• 2 Speiser PW, White PC. Congenital adrenal hyperplasia.  N Engl J Med. 2003;  349 776-788
• 3 Merke DP, Bornstein SR. Congenital adrenal hyperplasia.  Lancet. 2005;  365 2125-2136
• 4 White PC, Speiser PW. Congenital adrenal hyperplasia due to 21-hydroxilase deficiency.  Endocr Rev. 2000;  21 245-291
• 5 Warne GL, Zajac JD. Disorders of sexual differentiation.  Endocrinol Metab Clin North Am. 1998;  4 945-966
• 6 New MI, Carlson A, Obeid J. et al . Prenatal diagnosis for congenital adrenal hyperplasia in 532 pregnancies.  J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2001;  86 5651-5657
• 7 Prader A. Der Genitalbefund beim Pseudohermphroditismus feminus des kongenitalen adrenogenitalen Syndroms: Morphologie, Häufigkeit, Entwicklung und Vererbung der verscheidenen Genitalformen.  Helv Pediatr Acta. 1954;  9 231-248
• 8 Schnitzer JJ. Surgical treatment of congenital adrenal hyperplasia.  Endocrinol Metab Clin North Am. 2001;  30 121-135
• 9 Clayton PE, Miller WL, Oberfield SE. et al . Consensus statement on 21-hydroxilase deficiency from the Lawson Wilkins Pediatric Endocrine Society and the European Society for Paediatric Endocrinology.  J Clin Endrinol Metab. 2002;  87 408-453
• 10 Rink RC, Adams MC. Feminizing genitoplasty: state of art.  World J Urol. 1998;  16 212-218
• 11 Bachega TASS, Madureira G, Brenlha EML. et al . Tratamento da hiperplasia supra-renal congênita por deficiência da 21-hidroxilase.  Arq Bras Endocrinol Metab. 2001;  45 64-72
• 12 Diamond M, Sigmundson HK. Management of intersexuality: guidelines for dealing with persons with ambiguous genitalia.  Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 1997;  151 1046-1050
• 13 Creighton SM. Feminizing genital surgery: what should be done and when?.  J Pediatr Adolesc Gynecol. 2005;  18 63-69
• 14 Hendren WH, Donahoe PK. Correction of congenital abnormalities of the vagina and perineum.  J Pediatr Surg. 1980;  15 751-763
• 15 Snyder  III  HM, Retik AB, Bauer SB, Colodny AH. Feminizing genitoplasty: a synthesis.  J Urol. 1983;  129 1024-1026
• 16 Donahoe PK, Gustafson ML. Early one-stage surgical reconstruction of the extremely high vagina in patients with congenital adrenal hyperplasia.  J Pediatr Surg. 1994;  29 352-358
• 17 Young, Young H.. 1937 . Genital Abnormalities, Hermaphroditism and Related Adrenal Diseases. Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins 1937
• 18 Hampson JG. Hermaphroditic genital appearance, rearing and eroticism in hyperadrenocorticism.  Bull Johns Hopkins Hosp. 1955;  96 265-273
• 19 Gross RE, Randolph J, Crigler  Jr  JF. Clitorectomy for sexual abnormalities: indications and technique.  Surgery. 1966;  59 300-308
• 20 Sircilli MHP, Mendonça BB, Denes FT. et al . Anatomical and functional outcomes of feminizing genitoplasty for ambiguous genitalia in patients with virilizing congenital adrenal hyperplasia.  Clinics. 2006;  61 209-214
• 21 Minto CL, Liao LM, Woodhouse CRJ. et al . The effect of clitoral surgery on sexual outcome in individuals who have intersex conditions with ambiguous genitalia: a cross-sectional study.  Lancet. 2003;  361 1252-1257
• 22 Lattimer JK. Relocation and recession of the enlarged clitoris with preservation of the glans: an alternative to amputation.  J Urol. 1961;  86 113-116
• 23 Newman K, Randolph J, Anderson K. The surgical management of infants and children with ambiguous genitalia.  Ann Surg. 1992;  215 645-653
• 24 Schmid M. Plastische Korrektur der äußeren Genitale bei einem männlichen Scheinzwitter.  Langenbecks Arch Klin Chir. 1961;  298 977
• 25 Shaw A. Subcutaneous reduction clitoroplasty.  J Pediatr Surg. 1977;  12 331-338
• 26 Barrett TM, Gonzales  Jr  ET. Reconstruction of the female external genitalia.  Urol Clin North Am. 1980;  7 455-463
• 27 Glassberg KI, Laungani G. Reduction clitoroplasty.  Urology. 1981;  17 604-605
• 28 Mollard P, Juskiewenski S, Sarkissian J. Clitoroplasty in intersex: a new technique.  Br J Urol. 1981;  53 371-373
• 29 Rajfer J, Ehrlich RM, Goodwin WE. Reduction clitoroplasty via ventral approach.  J Urol. 1982;  128 341-343
• 30 Kogan SJ, Smey P, Levitt SB. Subtunical total reduction clitoroplasty: a safe modification of existing techniques.  J Urol. 1983;  130 746-748
• 31 Gearhart JP, Burnett A, Owen JH. Measurment of pudendal evoked potentials during feminizing genitoplasty: technique and applications.  J Urol. 1995;  153 486-487
• 32 Baskin LS, Erol A, Li YW. et al . Anatomical studies of the human clitoris.  J Urol. 1999;  162 1015-1020
• 33 Yang J, Felsen D, Poppas DP. Nerve sparing ventral clitoroplasty: analysis of clitoral sensivity and viability.  J Urol. 2007;  178 1598-1601
• 34 Poppas DP, Hochsztein AA, Baergen RN. et al . Nerve sparing ventral clitoroplasty preserves dorsal nerves in congenital adrenal hyperplasia.  J Urol. 2007;  178 1802-1806
• 35 Braga LH, Lorenzo AJ, Tatsuo ES. et al . Prospective evaluation of feminizing genitoplasty using partial urogenital sinus mobilization for congenital adrenal hyperplasia.  J Urol. 2006;  176 2199-2204
• 36 Pippi Salle JL, Braga LH, Macedo N. et al . Corporeal sparing dismembered clitoroplasty: an alternative technique for feminizing genitoplasty.  J Urol. 2007;  178 1796-1801
• 37 Farkas A, Chertin B, Hadas-Halpren I. 1-stage feminizing genitoplasty: 8 years of experience with 49 cases.  J Urol. 2001;  165 2341-2346
• 38 Farkas A, Chertin B. Feminizing genitoplasty in patients with 46XX congenital adrenal hyperplasia.  J Pediatr Endocrinol Metab. 2001;  14 713-722
• 39 Jones HW, Jones GES. The gynecological aspects of adrenal hyperplasia and allied disorders.  Am J Obstet Gynecol. 1954;  68 1330-1365
• 40 Fortunoff S, Lattimer JK, Edson M. Vaginoplasty technique for female pseudohermaphrodites.  Surg Gynecol Obstet. 1964;  118 545-548
• 41 Freitas-Filho L, Carnevale J, Melo CE. et al . A posterior-based omega-shaped flap vaginoplasty in girls with congenital adrenal hyperplasia caused by 21-hydroxylase deficiency.  BJU Int. 2003;  91 263-264
• 42 Hendren WH, Crawford JD. Adrenogenital syndrome: the anatomy of the anomaly and its repair.  J Pediatr Surg. 1969;  4 49-58
• 43 Passerini-Glazel G. A new 1-stage procedure for clitorovaginoplasty in severely masculinized female pseudohermaphrodites.  J Urol. 1989;  142 565-568
• 44 De Jong TPVM, Boemers TML. Neonatal management of female intersex by clitorovaginoplasty.  J Urol. 1995;  154 830-832
• 45 Gonzalez R, Fernandes ET. Single-stage feminization genitoplasty.  J Urol. 1990;  143 776-778
• 46 Powell DM, Newman KD, Randolph J. A proposed classification of vaginal anomalies and their surgical correction.  J Pediatr Surg. 1995;  30 271-276
• 47 Peña A. Total urogenital mobilization – an easier way to repair cloacas.  J Pediatr Surg. 1997;  32 263-268
• 48 Rink RC, Pope JC, Kropp BP. et al . Reconstruction of the high urogenital sinus: early perineal prone approach without division of the rectum.  J Urol. 1997;  158 1293-1297
• 49 Di Benedetto V, Gioviale M, Bagnara V. et al . The anterior sagittal transanorectal approach: a modified approach to 1-stage clitoral vaginoplasty in severely masculinized female pseudohermaphrodites — preliminary results.  J Urol. 1997;  157 330-332
• 50 Dòmini R, Rossi F, Ceccarelli PL. et al . Anterior sagittal transanorectal approach to the urogenital sinus in adrenogenital syndrome: preliminary report.  J Pediatr Surg. 1997;  32 714-716
• 51 Rink RC, Adams MC, Misseri R. A new classification for genital ambiguity and urogenital sinus anomalies.  BJU Int. 2005;  95 638-642
• 52 Ludwikowski B, Hayward IO, Gonzalez R. Total urogenital sinus mobilization: expanded applications.  BJU Int. 1999;  83 820-822
• 53 Jenak R, Ludwikowski B, Gonzalez R. Total urogenital sinus mobilization: a modified perineal approach for feminizing genitoplasty and urogenital sinus repair.  J Urol. 2001;  165 2347-2349
• 54 Ganesan A, Smith GHH, Broome K. et al . Congenital adrenal hyperplasia: preliminary observations of the urethra in 9 cases.  J Urol. 2002;  167 275-279
• 55 Braga LH, Silva IN, Tatsuo ES. Total urogenital sinus mobilization in the repair of ambiguous genitalia in children with congenital adrenal hyperplasia.  Arq Bras Endocrinol Metabol. 2005;  49 908-915
• 56 Rink RC, Metcalfe PD, Cain MP. et al . Use of the mobilized sinus with total urogenital mobilization.  J Urol. 2006;  176 2205-2211
• 57 Rink R, Kaefer M. Surgical management of intersexuality, cloacal, malformation, and other abnormalities of the genitalia in girls. In: Kavoussi LR, Novick AC, Partin AW, Wein CA, editors. Campbell – Walsh Urology. 9th ed. Philadelphia: Saunder-Elsevier 2007 pp 3830-3869
• 58 Rink RC, Metcalfe P, Cain M. et al . Partial urogenital mobilization: the advantages without the risks.  J Pediatr Urol. 2005;  1 232-233
• 59 Rink RC, Metcalfe PD, Kaefer MA. et al . Partial urogenital mobilization: a limited proximal dissection.  J Pediatr Urol. 2006;  2 351-356
• 60 Leslie JA, Cain MP, Rink RC. Feminizing genital reconstruction in congenital adrenal hyperplasia.  Indian J Urol. 2009;  25 17-26
• 61 Creighton SM, Minto CL, Steele SJ. Objective cosmetic and anatomical outcomes at adolescence of feminizing surgery for ambiguous genitalia done in childhood [letter].  Lancet. 2001;  358 124-125
• 62 Hanza AF, Soliman HA, Abdel Hay SA. et al . Total urogenital sinus mobilization in the repair of cloacal anomalies and congenital adrenal hyperplasia.  J Pediatr Surg. 2001;  36 1656-1658
• 63 Gozalbez R, Castellan M, Ibrahim E. et al . New concepts in feminizing genitoplasty – is the Fortunoff flap obsolete?.  J Urol. 2005;  174 2350-2353
• 64 Roll MF, Kneppo C, Roth H. et al . Feminizing genitoplasty: one-stage genital reconstruction in congenital adrenal hyperplasia: 30 years’ experience.  Eur J Pediatr Surg. 2006;  16 329-333
• 65 Savanelli A, Alicchio F, Esposito C. et al . A modified approach for feminizing genitoplasty.  World J Urol. 2008;  26 517-520
• 66 Farhat WA. Early intervention of CAH surgical management.  J Pediatr Adolesc Gynecol. 2005;  18 66-69
• 67 Passerini-Glazel G. Feminizing genitoplasty [editorial].  J Urol. 1999;  1592-1593
• 68 Gearhart JP. [editorial comment].  BJU Int. 2000;  86 258-259
• 69 American Academy of Pediatrics, Committee on Genetics . Evaluation of the newborn with developmental anomalies of the external genitalia.  Pediatrics. 2000;  106 138-142
• 70 Miller Wl, Oberfield SE, Speiser PW. et al . Regarding the consensus statement on 21-hydroxilase deficiency from the Lawson Wilkins Pediatric Endocrine Society and the European Society for Paediatric Endocrinology [letter].  J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2003;  88 3456
• 71 Nihoul-Fèkété C. Surgical management of the intersex patient: an overview in 2003 [lecture].  J Pediatr Surg. 2004;  39 144-145
• 72 Alizai NK, Thomas DFM, Lilford RJ. et al . Feminizing genitoplasty for congenital adrenal hyperplasia: what happens at puberty?.  J Urol. 1999;  161 1588-1591
• 73 Krege S, Walz KH, Hauffa BP. et al . Long-term follow-up of female patients with congenital adrenal hyperplasia from 21-hydroxilase deficiency, with special emphasis on the results of vaginoplasty.  BJU Int. 2000;  86 253-259
• 74 Gastaud F, Bouvattier C, Duranteau L. et al . Impaired sexual and reproductive outcomes in women with classical forms of congenital adrenal hyperplasia.  J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2007;  92 1391-1396
• 75 Göllü G, Yildiz RV, Bingol-Kologlu M. et al . Ambiguous genitalia: an overview of 17 years’ experience.  J Pediatr Surg. 2007;  42 840-844
• 76 Glassberg KI. Gender assignment and the pediatric urologist [editorial].  J Urol. 161 1308-1310
• 77 Eroglu E, Tekant G, Gündogdu G. et al . Feminizing surgical management of intersex patients.  Pediatr Sug Int. 2004;  20 543-547
• 78 Rangecroft L. Surgical management of ambiguous genitalia.  Arch Dis Child. 2003;  88 799-801
• 79 Creighton SM, Liao LM. Changing attitudes to sex assignment in intersex.  BJU Int. 2004;  93 659-664
• 80 Nabhan ZM, Rink RC, Eugster EA. Urinary tract infections in children with congenital adrenal hyperplasia.  J Pediatr Endocrinol Metab. 2006;  19 815-820
• 81 Kryger JV, González. Urinary continence is well preserved after total urogenital mobilzation.  J Urol. 2004;  172 2384-2386
• 82 Miranda ML, Oliveira Filho AG, Lemos-Marini SHV. et al . Labioscrotal island flap in feminizing genitoplasty.  J Pediatr Surg. 2004;  39 1030-1033
• 83 Davies MC, Crouch NS, Woodhouse CRJ. et al . Congenital adrenal hyperplasia and lower tract symptoms.  BJU Int. 2005;  95 1263-1266
• 84 Celayir S, Ilçe Z, Danismend N. Effects of male sex hormones on urodynamics in childhood: intersex patients are a natural model.  Pediatr Surg Int. 2000;  16 502-504
• 85 Money J, Hampson JG, Hampson JL. Hermaphroditism: recommendations concerning assignment of sex, change of sex, and psychologic management.  Bull Johns Hopkins Hosp. 1955;  97 284-300
• 86 Zucker KJ. Intersexuality and gender differentiation.  J Pediatr Adolec Gynecol. 2002;  15 3-13
• 87 Reiner WG. Sex assignment in the neonate with intersex or inadequate genitalia.  Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 1997;  151 1044-1045
• 88 Woodhouse CRJ. Intersex surgery in the adult.  BJU Int. 2004;  93 ((Suppl 3)) 57-65
• 89 Creighton SM, Ransley P, Duffy P. et al . Regarding the consensus statement on 21-hydroxilase deficiency from the Lawson Wilkins Pediatric Endocrine Society and the European Society for Paediatric Endocrinology [letter].  J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2003;  88 3455
• 90 Creighton SM. Long-term outcome of feminization surgery: the London experience.  BJU Int. 2004;  93 ((Suppl 3)) 44-46
• 91 Stikkelbroeck NMML, Beerendonk CCM, Willemsen WNP. et al . The long term outcome of feminizing genital surgery for congenital adrenal hyperplasia: anatomical, functional and cosmetic outcomes, psychosexual development, and satisfaction in adult female patients.  J Pediatr Adolesc Gynecol. 2003;  16 289-296
• 92 Gupta DK, Shilpa S, Amini AC. et al . Congenital adrenal hyperplasia: long-term evaluation of feminizing genitoplasty and psychosocial aspects.  Pediatr Surg Int. 2006;  22 905-909
• 93 Zucker KJ, Bradley SJ, Oliver G. et al . Psychosexual development of women with congenital adrenal hyperplasia.  Horm Behav. 1996;  30 300-318
• 94 Meyer-Bahlburg HFL, Gruen RS, New MI. et al . Gender change from female to male in classical congenital adrenal hyperplasia.  Horm Behav. 1996;  30 319-332
• 95 Berenbaum SA, Bailey M. Effects on gender identity of prenatal androgens and genital appearance: evidence from girls with congenital adrenal hyperplasia.  J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2003;  88 1102-1106
• 96 Berenbaum AS, Bryk KK, Duck SC. Psychological adjustment in children and adults with congenital adrenal hyperplasia.  J Pediatr. 2004;  144 741-746
• 97 Consortium on the management of disorders of sex development.  Clinical guidelines for the management of disorders of sex development in childhood. Rohnert Park: Intersex Society of North America [cited 15 Dec 2007]. Available from: http://www.dsdguidelines.org/htdocs/clinical/index.html 2006 ▪
• 98 Özbey H, Darendeliler F, Kayserili H. et al . Gender assignment in female congenital adrenal hyperplasia: a difficult experience.  BJU Int. 2004;  94 388-391
• 99 Meyer-Bahlburg HFL. Gender and sexuality in classical congenital adrenal hyperplasia.  Endocrinol Metab Clin North Am. 2001;  30 155-171
• 100 Wisniewski AB, Migeon CJ, Malouf MA. et al . Psychosexual outcome in women affected by congenital adrenal hyperplasia due to 21-hydroxilase deficiency.  J Urol. 2004;  171 2497-2501
• 101 Daaboul J, Frader J. Ethics and the management of the patient with intersex: a middle way.  J Pediatr Endocrinol Metab. 2001;  14 1575-1583
• 102 Lee PA, Witchel SF. Genital surgery among females with congenital adrenal hyperplasia: changes over the past five decades.  J Pediatr Endocrinol Metab. 2002;  15 1473-1477
• 103 Maharaj NR, Dhai A, Wiersma R. et al . Intersex conditions in children and adolescents: surgical, ethical, and legal considerations.  J Pediatr Adolesc Gynecol. 2005;  18 399-402
• 104 Dayner JE, Lee PA, Houk CP. Medical treatment of intersex: parenteral perspectives.  J Urol. 2004;  172 1762-1765
• 105 Graziano K, Teitelbaum DH, Hirschl RB. et al . Vaginal reconstruction for ambiguous genitalia and congenital absence of the vagina: a 27-year experience.  J Pediatr Surg. 2002;  37 955-960
• 106 Consensus statement on the management of intersex disorders by the Lawson Wilkins Pediatric Society and the European Society for Paediatric Endocrinology.  Pediatrics. 2006;  118 488-500

Correspondence